Before the premiere of Big Mistakes on April 9, 2026, expectations were high for Dan Levy, the creative force behind the beloved series Schitt’s Creek. Fans of the Emmy-winning show anticipated a similar blend of humor and heart, but with a fresh twist. Levy’s previous success had set a high bar, and many wondered if he could capture the same magic in a new setting.
However, the landscape shifted dramatically when Levy announced his new project. Big Mistakes is an eight-episode crime comedy that centers on two siblings, Nicky and Morgan Dardano, who find themselves entangled in the chaotic world of organized crime. This decisive moment marked a departure from the quaint charm of Schitt’s Creek, showcasing a more chaotic and edgy narrative style. The show quickly made waves, debuting at #2 on Netflix’s Top 10 list and earning a remarkable Rotten Tomatoes score of 95% based on 19 reviews.
The immediate effects of this shift were palpable. Fans who adored the quirky, heartwarming dynamics of Schitt’s Creek were introduced to a different kind of family story—one filled with chaos and humor. Levy, who serves as the showrunner, executive producer, and lead actor, expressed his excitement, stating, “I’m so excited to be bringing this truly chaotic family story to life with Netflix.” This enthusiasm resonated with audiences, contributing to an audience score of 78% for the series.
Critics have noted the unique blend of humor and tension in Big Mistakes. A review from Vulture highlighted the show’s ability to maintain a fun atmosphere even amidst serious situations, saying, “Even when it’s not being sweet, or when Nicky and Morgan are sincerely terrified about what’s happening to them, the trappings around them are so heightened and silly that Big Mistakes can’t help but come across as mostly a fun time.” This perspective emphasizes the show’s balance of comedy and chaos, a hallmark of Levy’s storytelling.
Moreover, the loss of Catherine O’Hara in January 2026, who played a pivotal role in Schitt’s Creek, added a layer of poignancy to Levy’s new venture. Her passing halted potential sequel plans for the original series, prompting Levy to channel his creative energy into Big Mistakes. This transition reflects not only a personal journey but also a professional evolution, as Levy explores new themes and narratives.
Expert voices in the entertainment industry have weighed in on this shift as well. A commentator from CBR remarked, “There’s something inherently funny about chaos erupting around two people who are too busy arguing about something trivial to notice the bigger picture.” This insight captures the essence of Big Mistakes, where humor arises from the absurdity of the characters’ situations, contrasting sharply with the more grounded humor of Schitt’s Creek.
As audiences embrace this new chapter in Levy’s career, the success of Big Mistakes serves as a testament to his versatility as a creator. The show not only stands on its own merits but also highlights the evolution of storytelling in the comedy genre. While the warmth and charm of Schitt’s Creek will always hold a special place in viewers’ hearts, Big Mistakes invites them to explore a different kind of family dynamic—one that is chaotic, humorous, and undeniably engaging.
